Pages

29 October 2026

Reflective questions

A student struggling to write an answer

An attempt to answer a question reflecting on what I've learned and developed during an assignment. No, it's actually just a rant tapped out whilst struggling to come up with an answer.

Going through yet another of these blasted questions makes me wonder if there's really any point to them. Perhaps we would all do better if we weren't tortured by them. During the period of this assignment the new Masters of the Universe film has come out in cinemas and bombed. Maybe that's a subtle hint that we don't all need to end our days declaring what we learned "in today's adventure" even if there isn't some annoying little wizard floating about in real life. Or perhaps my age is such that I'm one of the few who actually understands what the **** I'm on about. (Unfortunately the film is almost completely out of cinemas now so you'll have to wait for it to be streamed. Or try some of the old cartoons which can be found on YouTube.)

But none of this is getting my answer anywhere, though it does get the fingers flowing as I tap out a whole load of nonsense that I could never possibly submit. Still it's better than just sitting staring at a blank screen for ages, occasionally interrupted by turning over to see the latest news but I'm not going to put what particular story I'm following here because that will give the game away as to when this absolute load of ******** was written.

How has any of this developed me as an individual? Well it's given me another opportunity to be cynical and sarcastic. And I've just realised I don't actually need to adhere to or aim for the word count in this particular piece so I can just stop it right now. So there.

Obviously, this was written back during the summer so the Masters of the Universe film is long out of cinemas now and has been available on streaming for ages now. And it has done quite well on streaming so maybe it has more to say about reflective messages than I realised at the time I was tapping this out in desperation.

(Image created with Microsoft 365 Copilot.)

26 October 2026

Balancing study and life time

A balance of studying and life

It is perhaps a universal truth that all students at some stage struggle to balance the competing demands of their studying and their life away from their courses. This is as true with distance learning as with physical attendance courses.

At physical attendance "bricks and mortar" institutions there is a structure of classes, divided between lecturers, seminars, tutorials, lab sessions and so forth. But a lot of learning is expected outside these formal hours. Just how much can vary - for example when I did my first degree there was a lot of surprise when humanities and science students compared their timetables. One of the main differences was the science students usually had timetabled sessions in laboratories or computer rooms or on other specialised equipment whereas the humanities student was (supposed) to do a lot of reading that did not require formal sessions to be timetabled. But regular sessions of whatever kind provide a clear target for getting work done. Full-time students were expected to have enough time for this although the growing number of students doing part-time jobs did at times cause strain on timetabling demands. Part-time students would have more outside of their studies to balance with but again they had the benefit of the timetable to aim for.

By contrast with distance learning flexibility can be both a benefit and a curse. Once upon a time the Open University's televised lectures did at least force students into some semblance of timetable (even if the lectures themselves were sometimes broadcast at very anti-social hours) but the rise of first timeshifting and now online delivery has removed that timetable. The modules are designed around a nominal week by week order with the tutorials intended to align with them, but many students work at different paces and a lot use recordings of the tutorials to catch up.

Life outside of studying can be difficult to predict. Sometimes one can find themselves with much more free time than expected. At other times one can find a lot happening all at once - and often it happens at the same time as one's assignment is due. So one's schedule for doing a module can get thrown. Even when the timetable is kept to, a heavy day can leave one feeling drained and exhausted, not in the mood to start learning. It can be difficult to balance it all.

Nevertheless, there are ways to balance it all. Wherever possible, it's best that one's studying is not kept a secret. If others around one are already aware of the additional demands in life, they're more likely to be understanding and helpful when things go wrong. It is very advisable to set aside specific times for studying and insist on them being kept clear of other demands so there is a routine with sufficient time available. Sometimes it won't be possible to stick exactly to the schedule of both life and the course but times can be swapped. But one shouldn't let things just pile up with the assumption there will be plenty of time to fix it all later.

There will be unexpected events and demands. Some of those may have be ignored but others can't. But with planning and determination it is possible to balance the competing demands of studying, working, family and social life. Sacrifices here and there will have to be made but the outcome will be rewarding.

Also one must make sure to be in contact with tutors and/or the support teams. They are all too aware that students have other demands in their life and they are willing to help. It is possible to get extensions on some deadlines but not all and the students who are upfront about competing demands will find it easier to get the support and extensions they need.

Finally everyone should remember the best advice of all. "DON'T PANIC!"

(Image created with Microsoft 365 Copilot.)

22 October 2026

Open University Students' Union - The Student Summit


Student representation can be confusing, not just for those outside the institution but even those within it. Odd structures exist, acronyms abound, different terminology is used at different institutions and it's not always clear just what role or body does what.

And there's a strange media portrayal that uses the term "students' union politics" disparagingly, to the point that many ex-students' union officers in public life try to downplay their experience rather than being proud of what they did.

The reality is that most people who get involved in and serve roles in students' unions do so because they want to help their fellow students and give something back to others. They are not doing it as an early step up the political career ladder. And whilst there are obsessions with external political matters, particularly events in a certain part of the world, these are not the day-to-day obsessions of students' union officers who are focused more on ensuring students can get through their courses smoothly and get effective resolution to problems.

The student representative body at the Open University has gone through some changes in recent years. It has changed the name from "Open University Students' Association" to "Open SU", reflecting the general common use of "students' union" across the UK. They're also repackaging their biennial (every two years) conference as the "Student Summit", an online event to bring students together for more than just formal business.

The formal resolutions for the event have been published and they're all pretty straightforward organisational matters. Four are straightforward things you find on most organisations' annual general meetings - approving minutes, reports, accounts and appointing auditors. One is virtually a blank motion reviewing affiliations but as Open SU doesn't have any (it isn't affiliated to the National Union of Students) then this means little in practice. The other two are about officer roles. One is to rename the "European Representative" to "International Representative". The other is to undertake a review of how underrepresented students are represented in the Open SU's structures but this is just to hold a review, not to make any changes at this stage. Any student can vote. Notably absent from the agenda of the largest students' union in the country are divisive resolutions about events in the world that are not within the organisation's aims.

This is far from all the Student Summit will be doing, with speakers (including Rose Ayling-Ellis), opportunities to connect and more. It's a very different approach from the students' union general meetings of my previous universities, focused on motions ranging from campus improvements to world politics (these were often voted down in my day).

The Student Summit will be held online on 21 November 2026. All current Open University students "who have studied with the OU within the last two years and have yet to complete their qualification" are eligible to attend but they must first vote on the resolutions online.

(Image taken from the Open SU website to illustrate commentary.)

19 October 2026

Interactive Computer Marked Assignments

The letters iCMA on a white background

One of the ways the Open University assesses students is through an iCMA, or "Interactive Computer Marked Assignment". As the name implies, these are marked by computer and tend to be straightforward with clear right and wrong answers.

iCMAs (no, I don't know why they're capitalised like that) can come in multiple forms across different modules and subjects. Not all modules have them though. When doing Level 2 all my modules had one iCMA, usually near the start of the course, which tested whether I had grasped the material in the course so far through a series of multiple choice questions. Each iCMA was effectively an open book, untimed exam testing understanding and comprehension. Other iCMAs may differ, perhaps setting the student a specific task or scenario and working around them. Some appear to have stricter time limits from when they can be opened to when they must be submitted. There are many different forms.

Therefore, it's not possible to give too much general advice around them. It's critical to read the instructions for each first before opening them to make sure if they can be completed in all the time before the deadline or if one has only a limited number of days after opening. They should be approached calmly and without stress. If there's plenty of time available then a good strategy is to go through the questions at least three times on three separate days, thinking carefully about each one to determine if the right answer has been selected.

It's also important to not neglect iCMAs, even if the deadline comes at a busy period. If one is taking more than one module at a time the deadlines can sometimes stack up. Looking at the study planners for the different years there are a number of module combinations that can result in the iCMA in one module having a deadline close to that for either another iCMA or a Tutor Marked Assignment (TMA) in a different module. As well as effecting full-time students taking multiple modules simultaneously this can also occur in the six weeks around February when the half-year modules overlap.

I am about to embark on the only iCMA I am aware of for any of my Level 3 modules. (Some of these posts are written in advance.) The previous iCMAs were good for keeping me on my toes. Now it's time to see how difficult this one is.

(Image created with Microsoft 365 Copilot.)

15 October 2026

Why you shouldn't use AI for assignments

An anti Artificial Intelligence (AI) symbol

Yes I know I use Artificial Intelligence (something of a misnomer at times) for this blog. But I use it only for generating images that look much better than anything I could come up with manually. They're very simple with straightforward descriptions used to create them. And this blog is not submitted for formal assessment.

That's a very different thing from using it to write assignments. Or, worse, legal documents. The Empty City blog has a good breakdown of a case where a submission cited no less than five cases that don't exist, but this was not obvious without looking up the references that seemed plausible - see the post A close reading of the “AI” fake cases judgment.

Because with AI one has no certainty of sources. AI submissions often contain made up case references. Or they might cite a genuine case but from a different country - for example how do you know if a legal case involving Ms Jones and the City of Newcastle is about something that happened in the North East of England or in New South Wales? Or they might assume a law in, say, New Zealand applies here. A lot of writing about Law on the internet is poor, badly researched and often does not make it clear just what jurisdiction it refers to, or clarity is assumed from the place of original publication. So AI scanning the web for materials often comes up with a mishmash of information that bears little resemblance to reality.

Even if one can control the information going into AI there is still no guarantee the analysis will match up, even if one does manually modify the text afterwards. It's really best avoided completely.

(Image created with Microsoft 365 Copilot subject to very specific instructions and this is not a formal submission for anything.)

12 October 2026

How useful is the OU app?

Open University app entry screen

Over the years the Open University has embraced all manner of technology to deliver course material to its students. It has mailed out umpteen books, sheets and other printed materials. It has used radio, television and the internet to broadcast or send out material. It has used many different portable media formats to deliver them to students. It will no doubt continue to find new ways to do so.

But one of its less successful ventures of recent years has been its study app, OU Study.

I'm far from alone in finding it disappointing as the terrible reviews on Google Play show, with many users reporting problems logging on or having difficulties opening materials. My own experience has been with many problems with the latter. Sometimes I've sat down somewhere, got out the app in the hope of opening it to read something . . . only for it to take an eternity to load the module material and so instead of facilitating calm study it just generates frustration and puts me completely out of the mindset to use it.

That's even before we get onto the problems with the study materials themselves. Many of the more interactive elements simply don't work in the app. And often it's not really advisable to skip past an activity to come back later as it breaks the flow of study. So the app offers very little of use when studying, maybe just an opportunity to refresh information on a particular page, but it isn't really much use for actually advancing through the course materials.

Open University app jammed menu screen

In preparing for this post I decided to open the app to get some screenshots to help describe the experience. The app didn't want to play ball. This should be showing my current modules, but it instead jammed on the opening screen and eventually I gave up and just took a screenshot of that.

Now it's possible there are other devices on which the app works perfect and some modules may have more app friendly course materials that don't come with so many omissions. But it's also clear from the online reviews that I'm far from the only person who finds this app to be not only useless but also potentially counter-productive given the way frustrations with it can put people off from doing any studying there and then.

Maybe one day the OU will come up with a much better app that's able to take the website experience and convert it into a form that works well on a smartphone. Perhaps if it comes soon enough I'll still be studying with the OU and can revisit this post to discuss a much improved app. But for now the app is just not useful at all.

(Screenshots my own, modified to remove personal details.)

08 October 2026

Are the Foundations of Legal Knowledge still relevant?

Textbooks for the Foundations of Legal Knowledge

The debate around core subjects in the legal curriculum seems to be endless. There have been numerous reviews and changes over the years. So are the Foundations of Legal Knowledge still relevant?

There are two ways to approach this. One is the question of whether there should be any compulsory subjects at all. The other is whether the current seven are the right ones.

The first question has been shaken up by the reforms to the solicitors' route to qualification that have effectively abolished not only compulsory subjects on a Law degree but even the requirement to have a Law degree or conversion diploma at all. The SQE requires study of "Functioning Legal Knowledge", but the set-up allows it to adapt quickly to changing needs and the knowledge is tested through the SQE exam itself, rather than in the degree. So there's less of a need to prescribe a compulsory element of the degree curriculum that gets discussed at length by multiple involved parties and then locked in for years.

By contrast the barristers' route still requires academic study of specific areas of Law. And given how Law is built on statutes and cases, not just theory, then short of a radical overhaul of the route to something similar to the SQE, it's hard to argue that study of some core legal subjects isn't necessary. But it must also be acknowledged that the academic stage is only part of the route to becoming a barrister and some of the more practical areas may be better left to the vocational stage with the Bar [Whatever Middle Words Are Used This Week] Course.

Most of the current seven seem obvious choices even if not every lawyer will work with every single one in their career. For example, many lawyers may never do anything with Criminal Law but will need to at least recognise it and direct enquirers. The one which does stand out as the most obvious choice to drop is European Union Law, but that's very much a debate in its own right. Evidence Law is compulsory for prospective barristers and solicitors in Northern Ireland but may be a little too niche to add as a compulsory subject overall or else it might be best left to the vocational stage.

But are there other areas of Law that should be compulsory as well? Here it gets into the risk of picking favourites and there's the overall question of just how much a degree can take, especially if each compulsory subject has 30 credits and then there also has to be provision for basics like legal skills, the legal system and so forth that will also take up credits. Add too many subjects and there's a risk the degree becomes homogenised with very little space for options that allow students to pursue their own interests and academics to continue exploring particular fields. Alternatively, the number of credits and time devoted to each subject could contract to the point of barely skimming the surface.

Many countries have the same concept of an official list of subjects a student must have studied in order to qualify as a lawyer. Looking around requirements in other countries some patterns quickly emerge. Some countries do not separate out Contract Law and Tort Law. Some have Constitutional Law and Administrative Law as separate concepts and subjects. Equity & Trusts Law is generally a common law affair and this translates into the curriculums in various jurisdictions. And whilst EU Law appears to be compulsory in some non EU member countries (e.g. Norway), this is mainly down to particular ties and it's optional if offered at all in the rest of the world.

Common law countries, usually those with historic ties to the United Kingdom (not all are in the Commonwealth), tend to require students to study Administrative, Constitutional, Contract, Criminal, Equity & Trusts, Property and Tort Law, a very similar list to the Foundations though what is listed as Public Law here in the UK is often separated out. Civil law countries tend to structure things differently, usually into groups like Civil Law, Criminal Law and Public Law. But some countries have additional subjects as well.

As an example, Australia has what is known as the "Priestley 11", (named after Lancelot John Priestley who was the chair of the Law Admissions Consultative Committee (LACC) when these were set down). The eleven compulsory subjects are:

  • Administrative Law
  • Civil Dispute Resolution
  • Company Law
  • Contracts
  • Criminal Law and Procedure
  • Equity
  • Ethics and Professional Responsibility
  • Evidence
  • Federal and State Constitutional Law
  • Property
  • Torts

(It should be noted that law degrees traditionally either last longer or are more intensely packed in Australia than here.)

It would be wrong to make a subject compulsory simple because of how things are done in other countries. And there's also a risk of getting into debate about the relative importance of individual areas of Law to practice - is Company Law more commonly used than, say, Family Law? But there are some interesting entries on this list. And there's another example of Evidence Law being compulsory.

Courses like Ethics, Procedure and Civil Dispute Resolution can be done in a Law degree but are probably more appropriate for the vocational stage of training than the academic. Otherwise, we have another example of the strong similarity of courses around the globe.

Overall, it seems that most of the Foundations are considered essential not just here but across the common law world. It's hard to see how most of them could not be included in a basic standard law degree. There may be scope for refinement around the edges but given the current degree lengths it would be difficult to add too many more without either contracting the number of credits on each or over homogenising the degree at the expense of options. For now, it seems that the Foundations of Legal Knowledge are here to stay.

(Photograph my own.)

05 October 2026

How accurate is The Paper Chase?

It may not be the best known law school film, but many consider 1973's The Paper Chase to be the best and most accurate portrayal. Based on a book by a then-recent Harvard graduate John Jay Osborn, Jr., the film stars Timothy Bottoms, Lindsay Wagner and John Houseman:

It's a fine film and thoroughly recommended. But, regardless of how well it captures the experience of either Harvard or American law schools as a whole (and as Harvard is traditionally one of the top US law schools it's not necessarily representative), as with many screen portrayals the relationship to a distance learning Law degree in the UK is somewhat limited. It does capture well how Law is very much about theory and application and that the ability to remember umpteen facts is not sufficient or even necessary (hence why many students, lecturers and lawyers do not instantly recall every case). There's certainly plenty of reading of cases and statutes then discussing them. It shows that Contract Law is not the easiest of subjects or the one everyone enjoys, sentiments definitely shared by many on our WhatsApp group when we took the module.

And a couple of the cases discussed in the film are from English Law. Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co ([1893] 1 QB 256) is one of the best known of all contract cases and is discussed accurately in the film. Vigers v Cook ([1919] 2 KB 475) may be a little less well known (it didn't come up on my module nor is it covered in Poole's Casebook on Contract Law, at least not in the sixteenth edition) but is still an interesting precedent, especially as in the film the discussion of the case serves as background to a key silent confrontation between the protagonists whilst the rest of the class struggle to recall the facts of the case (as a starter, one of the parties' son died and the other party was the undertaker - but who was who?).

(The opening scene has brought to fame a case from New Hampshire, Hawkins v. McGee (84 NH 114, 146 A. 641 (1929)), also known as the "Hairy Hand" case. In part because of its appearance here, this case continues to be heavily used in American Contract Law classes, often at the start of the course, and is widely discussed. The opening scene delivers the common portrayal of the facts of the case but more recently this portrayal has been challenged, not least in a 2010 article by Daniel O'Gorman (full reference below) in which he went back to the original trial transcripts and came to some very different conclusions about the dispute. There's a good summary in Another Perspective on Dr. McGee and the Case of the Hairy Hand by Norman Otto Stockmeyer.)

But the classes in which the lecturer puts students through the fire with the Socratic Method of teaching, the study group trying to produce revision guides ("outlines") and descending into personal conflict, the chaotic preparation for exams, the intellectual struggle between the student and the lecturer and so forth all belong to a very different world from my studies. And results no longer come in envelopes, though as I've previously noted, it is still possible to make a paper aeroplane out of them in homage to the ending. As for the closeness to the US law school experience, here's Learn Law Better's take on it:

Still, it's definitely worth watching, especially for the Oscar winning performance of John Houseman as Professor Kingsfield, the Contract Law lecturer. There was later a television series as well in which Houseman reprised the role, but I've only seen the first episode and it's nowhere near as good.

Reference

O'Gorman, D. (2010) 'Expectation Damages, the Objective Theory of Contracts, and the 'Hairy Hand' Case: A Proposed Modification to the Effect of Two Classical Contract Law Axioms in Cases Involving Contractual Misunderstandings', Kentucky Law Journal, 99, pp.327-377. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2815050

01 October 2026

So just where is the Public Law banner image from?

The repeated Public Law symbol

The teaching website for each OU module comes with a special banner graphic that aims to represent the content of the module. It can be a cartoon image, a photograph, an AI image or a collage. Usually, it's clear what it represents and how it links to the module in question.

But one image in particular has stumped many a student. Just what is the repeated symbol on the Public Law banner and how does it relate to the subject?

The answer is surprisingly simple.

It's a picture of the carpet in the Supreme Court with its unique symbol.

The four plants represent the four nations of the United Kingdom:

  • A flax for Northern Ireland
  • A thistle for Scotland
  • A Tudor Rose for England
  • A leek for Wales

The symbol can be found repeatedly on many of the carpets in the Supreme Court building; this particular photograph was taken in Courtroom 2.


The four flowers can also be found on the formal badge of the court. Here's the one in Courtroom 2.

It's a surprisingly obvious image when you think about it. A glance at the covers of various Public Law textbooks show either abstract images or umpteen images of Parliament so it's nice to have some variety.

All these images were taken on a tour of the Court with members of the Open University Law Society as part of a very memorable evening. Both the Society and a visit to the Court are well recommended.

(All images my own.)